Acting Attorney General Matthew J. Platkin and Commissioner of Environmental Protection (DEP) Shawn M. LaTourette announced today that the DEP has filed suit against Ford Motor Co. over its contamination of hundreds of acres of soil, water, wetlands and other natural resources in Passaic County.
The lawsuit seeks compensation for Natural Resource Damages (NRDs) caused by Ford’s disposal, over many years, of toxic paint sludge and other pollutants within a former iron mining area known as Ringwood Mines in the Borough of Ringwood.
According to officials, among other things, the 500-acre Ringwood Mines area encompasses the historic homeland of the Ramapough Lenape Nation, a Native American Tribe formally recognized by the State.
Many of the approximately 200 residents who live within Ringwood Mines are Tribe members, and the community meets the criteria for an “overburdened community” as defined by New Jersey’s Environmental Justice Law aimed at equitably protecting low-income, minority and/or non-English speaking communities from environmental pollution. The site at issue is known as the Ringwood Mines/Landfill Superfund Site.
“Today, we hold Ford accountable for Natural Resource Damages -- for knowingly polluting some of the State’s most precious environmental assets, then walking away without disclosing the toxic mess they had made or attempting to mitigate the harm,” said Acting Attorney General Platkin.
“To other corporate polluters and anyone else so inclined, our message is simple: treat New Jersey’s air, land, and water like your own private dumping ground and we will not look the other way. We will hold you responsible, and we will make you pay.”
Filed today in New Jersey Superior Court, the State’s lawsuit alleges that Ford purchased Ringwood Mines in 1965 for the express purpose of using it as a landfill where it could dispose of hazardous waste generated by its auto assembly plant in Mahwah – at one time the largest auto assembly plant in the U.S.
According to officials, between 1967 and 1974, the complaint recounts, Ford disposed of thousands of tons of toxic paint sludge in the forests and on the grounds within Ringwood Mines, as well as in its abandoned mineshafts and pits.
Multiple other pollutants were dumped there as well, including various non-liquid pollutants and waste stored in drums.
Officials said that subsequently, Ford either donated or sold off all of its contaminated Ringwood Mines properties while fully aware – but without disclosing – that those properties were contaminated with hazardous and toxic wastes, the complaint notes.
Ford’s actions were “deliberate acts or omissions taken with a wanton and willful disregard for the welfare of the residents of New Jersey.”
They caused harm to the air, soil, groundwater, surface water, wetlands, and biota within Ringwood Mines, threatening human health, wildlife and aquatic life in the process.
Harmful substances found at the site include lead, arsenic, benzene, polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs), semi-volatile organic compounds, chrysene and 1,4 dioxane, a colorless solvent believed to be a carcinogen, as well as other pollutants.
According to officials, the contaminated property at issue includes abandoned pits, inactive landfills, open waste dumps and mineshafts.
The property also includes a municipal recycling center, a municipal garage and 48 private homes, as well as a portion of Ringwood State Park.
In 1970, Ford donated 290 acres of the site to Ringwood Borough, which used the donated acreage for a landfill.
Ford also donated 190 acres to DEP, which subsequently added the donated acreage to Ringwood State Park.
Between 1983 and 1994, EPA listed the property on its National Priorities List.
The site was deleted from the list in 1994 following Ford’s removal of about 8,300 cubic yards of paint sludge and soil.
Officials said that, however, newly discovered pockets of paint sludge were found on site in 1995, 1998 and 2004, and DEP testing of nearby residential properties in 2005 showed elevated lead levels in the soil.
In light of DEP’s discovery, lead-impacted soil and paint sludge were removed from affected residential properties.
Beginning in 2006, EPA reinstated Ringwood Mines to the National Priorities List.
According to officials, in 2019, Ford agreed to pay the State $2.1 million to cover DEP’s past costs related to cleanup and disposal of the paint sludge and other contaminants within Ringwood Mines.
The $2.1-million payment was part of a state-federal settlement that resolved allegations of liability for costs incurred by both DEP and the EPA as a result of Ford’s long-term dumping.
The same 2019 settlement called for Ford to perform cleanup work in a specific portion of the Ringwood Mines property designated as Operable Unit 2 and involved remediation of sections known as the Peters Pit Mine Area, the Cannons Mine Pit Area, and the O’Connor Disposal Area.
In addition to seeking compensation for lost natural resources, today’s lawsuit seeks punitive damages and penalties due to Ford’s “wanton and willful disregard for the people of New Jersey,” as shown by its discharge of hazardous substances directly into the environment, failure to notify DEP of those discharges, and Ford’s ongoing “concealment of the full extent of the contamination.”
The multi-count lawsuit specifically alleges violations of New Jersey’s Spill Compensation and Control Act, Water Pollution Control Act, and Solid Waste Management Act and also includes common law claims of strict liability, negligence, public nuisance and trespass.
The Ford Motor Co. matter is being handled by Deputy Attorneys General Thomas Lihan and Carley Doyle of the Environmental Enforcement and Environmental Justice (EEEJ) Section within the Division of Law’s Affirmative Civil Enforcement Practice Group, under the supervision of Assistant Attorney General Aaron Kleinbaum and Section Chief Gary W. Wolf II.